Global News : Passport : Ricks : Drezner : Walt : Rothkopf : Lynch
The Cable : The AfPak Blog : Net Effect : Shadow Govt. : Madam Secretary : The Call
The language of empire

Why English will keep America's influence from waning.
By Ali Wyne
It's easy to be pessimistic about the United States' standing in the world these days. The financial crisis shamed Wall Street for reckless behavior at a time when China's economic clout is fast rising. Leaders at the G-20 called for a multi-polar world, even as their prescriptions looked to be self-fulfilling. Even the U.S. National Intelligence Council concluded that the United States "will be less dominant" a quarter of the way into the new century in last year's Global Trends 2025 report.
But for those who claim that the post-American world is a fait accompli, there is one big problem: The English language is winning hearts and minds faster than politics ever can. With the June 10 addition of "noob" (a pejorative description of a newcomer to a particular task or group) to its lexicon, English will boast one million words - twice as many as Cantonese, four times as many as Spanish, and 10 times as many as French. Half the world's people are projected to be speaking English by 2015. And so long as English is on track to become the world's unofficial language, the United States will likely be center stage.
The stats say it all. In mid-2007, the International Herald Tribune stated that "English is spoken in some form by three times as many nonnative speakers as native speakers." English is a first language for 400 million people, and a fluent second for between 300 and 500 million more, the IHT wrote. Add on top of that the 750 million who have studied English as a foreign language and you have well over 1 billion members of the English-speaking world. Every globally influential newspaper is either written in English or has an English-language version. The same is nearly true for science, where more than 90 percent of the world's major journals are printed in English. With all this at stake, it's no surprise that the global market for English-as-a-second-language training products and services is worth $50 billion (that's more than Lithuania's 2008 GDP).
Why the English explosion? It's all about upward mobility. In China, America's putative superpower replacement, learning English is considered a gateway to middle-class security; 300 million people speak it there, and another 350 million people speak it in India. According to a recent report by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs, between 96 and 100 percent of people in China, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, and Vietnam believe children should learn English. Their goal is reflected in the more than 90 percent of Japanese elementary schools that offer English programs. Children in China start learning the language in third grade and more than 50,000 English-training centers there offer further instruction. Chris Gibson, the British Council's director for South India, aims to have every South Indian speaking it by 2010, at which point he believes that English will be a codified world language (Penguin Books' operations in India, meanwhile, are salivating at what they see as the world's fastest-growing English-language market).
Asian countries aren't alone in their anglophilia. Since 1998, Argentinean students have been required to take two hours of English per week from fourth grade through high school. That same year, Chile mandated that government-run schools begin offering English instruction starting in fifth rather than seventh grade. English is the language of choice in the classrooms of many African countries. And even continental Europe has placed growing emphasis on learning English. The Dean of MBA programs at France's ESSEC Business School, Laurent Bibard, told The New York Times that the school is adopting English because "it's the language for international teaching." English, he continued, "allows students to be able to come from anyplace in the world and for our students -- the French ones -- to go everywhere."
The trends suggest that English's influence is primed to increase in the decades ahead. Consider this forecast by the Director of Asia for the McKinsey Global Institute: "By 2100, the world will go from a 7,000-language planet to a couple of hundred languages at the most...English will be the major medium of communication in many countries and the second-most prevalent in China, Japan, Korea, and much of Africa and Latin America - as it already is in most of Europe."
Language quite literally anchors human progress - it allows children to learn, authors to write, consumers to buy, companies to produce, leaders to negotiate, people to travel, and enables just about anything else that you can imagine. Whether it's Latin during the first century or French in the 18th, great powers and global lingua francas tend to go together. So while the unipolar moment may be over, the growing influence of English will ensure that the United States doesn't fade into the sunset anytime soon.
Ali Wyne is a junior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
Photo: GOH CHAI HIN/AFP/Getty Images






English in China
While I agree with the main point of the article I think it is pretty misleading to count people who have passed through the Chinese education system as speakers of English. I teach English majors in rural China and can attest to the fact that they all get 6 years of English. This doesn't really qualify them as English speakers though, since nearly all of the focus is on reading and listening. Most students who pass through high-school can barely manage hello and bye-bye. I think this would be the equivalent of saying that all American high school students count as Spanish speakers after a couple years of study.
I think the emphasis should be on the fact that there is such a push by the government to teach the students English, and in large part there is a genuine interest in learning it. So your article would be suggesting that China's and India's education policies will be helping keep the U.S. on top. After traveling to more than 20 cities in China I find it hard to believe that nearly a quarter of Chinese people could be called "English speakers."
english education system
Well, I found it pretty good to mention that some countries have changed their education system concerning the english language. I mean like you mentioned, instead of fifth grade, it's forth right now. but the question is " did this change anything?" well, I don't think so.
Because, teachers are explaining the rules in the students native tang. so, does that make them english speakers? well, in some how I doute about that!
the growing influence of
the growing influence of English will ensure that the United States doesn't fade into the sunset anytime soon.
I guess that's also what keeps England from fading into the sunset....
Fitting Photo
According to your article nearly one third of the world's English speakers are in China. The photo your editors have chosen for this article couldn't be more fitting.
Your photo shows a picture of a woman in front of a poster with perhaps China's second best known slogan, the catch phrase for the Beijing 2008 Olympics. In the photo, the Chinese characters are correct, however the English is mis-spelled.
The real slogan should be "ONE WORLD - ONE DREAM", not One Word - One Dream!!
Great job China. Just another excellent example of proper English in China. Oops again. This is too Chinese - looks OK from a distance but on closer inspection...
The people of China are making strides to learn English, sometimes I even get surprised when a taxi driver can understand me but it will be a long time until a quarter of the people can really understand English. I live in Shenzhen, the situation is similar in other large first tier cities like Beijing/ Shanghai/ Guangzhou/ Dalian and much worse in most other cities.
It is impossible to think 300 million people can speak English in China, perhaps 300 million people can say Hello and Goodbye but that is the limit for most of them. At least it is better than nothing - and they are trying. Those who have been in China, know lots of people who can also add 'massage', prounounced MA-SA-GEE and "Jiggy-Jiggy" to the English vocabulary here. Maybe 300 million students have or are studying English but that does not mean they can speak or understand it.
China's best known slogan is "Made in China".
I've lived in China for too long.
Maybe we should ask the Portuguese...
I can sum up what I'm about to explain by saying that English in the mouth does not necessarily mean America in the conversation.
If history can tell us anything, the Portuguese didn't see an end to their reign either. Even though they gave Brazil Portuguese, Brazilian Portuguese is now more widely spoken than Portuguese proper. Middlebury College, which has one of the best language schools in the world teaches Brazilian Portuguese, and Portuguese proper is a sidebar. And the English, for who the English language is named didn't retain the influence in America that their language has.
Using those example, it would be unreasonable to conclude that one's influence is secure because said language usage is on the rise. This has been true for France, mainly on the African continent, but a more consistent pattern is for countries to take on a language and redefine it, as the Brazilians have done.
Also, the Chinese can use English to facilitate communication with other rising powers like India. So again, American English in the mouth is not always America in the conversation.
Fascination for English
In India there is a huge demand for English education even amongst the the poor, and they are willing to pay a huge premium (typically a significant fraction of their income) to get english education for their children. This is driven by the belief that it is the passport to success, as almost all higher education, private business & government activities is done in English. So without knowledge of English a person cannot compete. With increasing literacy & education levels India will have the largest population of english speakers. One sees english medium schools, and part time courses in english popping up everywhere.
Interestingly this desire to learn english is not limited to developing countries, but even US where even babies are taught to read before they can walk, see Your Baby Can Read
A non-native English
Unfortunately, this article does not acknowledge the quality of language people are speaking - several others have noted issues with China - European English speakers seem to have their own dialect of English. I'd argue that what is spoken in Europe is a *European* English that has a limited vocabulary, is completely free of idioms and irony, yet is straightforward and effective for business and unnuanced communication. This is also, in fact, the language that students are learning and that is employed in European postsecondary education. All those French students are able to go anywhere in Europe because all the other Europeans also speak this slightly choppy, hyper-pragmatic English - none of which has anything to do with continued U.S. dominance.
English in America
As much as English is gaining ground across the globe, it seems to be slipping here in America, with having to listen to customer service menu prompts that take twice as long ".. por Espanol mark el dos ..", bilingual signs, bilingual product instruction sheets, bilingual "education", etc. - mostly because of the influence of so many illegals coming here as parasites to feed at the public trough on our taxpayer's dollars while stealing identities and increasing violent crime, theft, graffiti, and drug trafficking.
Contrary to the article's central thesis: 1. America's industrial and financial influence IS waning worldwide, and 2. English in America is becoming ever more bastardized (Spanglish??) and ever less mandatory for its residents to function in its society. Are the two events related?
I love spanglish!
Lighten up, bludbaf!
Have you ever listened to the spanish radio stations in the Bay Area? You know what? Things like spanglish should be outlawed, outlawed for being fun and awesome at the same time.
I love and cherish the many interesting versions of English I hear spoken around me. I also enjoy learning to read Spanish phrases from dual language signs. Manos = Hands? Who knew? And what fun at the same time!
I hear that soon we may have to relearn English when we go overseas, because other countries will change it so profoundly.
This is a silly article.
This is a silly article. Language come and go. It is the hegemon which assures their hegemony, not vice versa.
Another way to look at this
Another way to look at this would be looking at U.S. currency, which has stayed relatively stable during this econmic mess. Not because our country is doing so well, but because the U.S. dollar is simply used by everyone else, it has really become the global currency for travelers everywhere. Is it possible that English will simply become detached from U.S. and British dominance like the dollar has?
One other thing to look at is in Malaysia there are 3 official languages: Malay, Chinese, and English. With Malaysia's still simmering racial tension English became the kind of ethnically neutral language.
This may be anglocentrism,
This may be anglocentrism, but I honestly can't think of a better language to be the universal lingua franca. English is just so wonderfully corrupt - it sucks in adjectives and words from whatever languages it collides into, and starts inserting its words into their vocabularies. Plus, it's so blunt!
English wud be fien after
English wud be fien after spelling reform.
English spelling iz atroshus. It maeks no centz.
ZOMG!
Leik i totttaly can see wot u tlking bout, i fink we cud get 2gether n tak sum moar!
Yes, while the rest of the world is learning how to speak English (semi-properly), the internet (interwebz!!!111oneone) is teaching Americans/English to speak improperly. Which really defeats the point of having a world-wide language.
Let's go back to Esperanto! (Hah!)
Battleship Reason
????? ????? ?????
????? ?????
????? ??????
?????
????